More website traffic sounds like the obvious way to get more leads or sales. But what if the real problem is what happens after people arrive?

Suppose 1,000 well-qualified visitors visit your site and 20 of them become leads. Let’s say that 20 of the 1,000 visitors who are well qualified become leads. This is a 2% conversion rate. You’ve now got 30 leads without adding additional traffic to your site or ranking for another keyword. You’ve now increased that same 1,000 visitors by 3% to 330 leads, without adding more traffic or ranking for another keyword.

That’s what website conversion optimization is all about: maximize the value you can derive from your existing website visitors.

If you’re interested in a more comprehensive overview of messaging, UX, calls to action, and usability, visit WP Minds’ Website Conversion Guide.

Start With the Conversion You Actually Want

When considering a button change or a new headline, you should have a clear definition of what a “conversion” is for your website.

It may be a quote request, a phone call, a request for a consultation, or a submission of a filled-out form. In ecommerce it can be a purchase or the checkout process. A newsletter sign-up or guide download could be a good secondary conversion.

To begin with, select one main conversion for every significant page. Then check out the way visitors get there.

1. Make the Value Clear Within Seconds

It shouldn’t be necessary for a visitor to explore your home page to discover what you do.

The first part of your paragraph should respond to:

  • What do you offer?
  • Who is it for?
  • What is the next step for the visitor?

Consider the following two examples:

Informative: “Developing innovative digital solutions to transform businesses.”

Clear stands out by stating that they create WordPress sites for professional service businesses that convert.

The second conveys to the visitor what the company does and who it serves. This clarity helps to make decisions on continuing to read the book.

If your homepage is having trouble here, check your hero section first before revamping your whole website. In How to Write a Website Hero Section That Converts, WP Minds shares how to combine the components of the headline, supporting copy, call to action, and page hierarchy.

2. Match the Page to Visitor Intent

Not all visitors are in the market to purchase.

If you are seeing the question “how does website conversion work?” on Google, you might still be researching. Making a decision is much closer when somebody is comparing website consulting companies.

Your page must reflect that purpose. If you are a first-time visitor, it’s best to familiarize yourself with the process, examples or read a guide before booking a call.

Consider what to do next:

Blog post → related guide → service page → consultation

WP Minds’ Website Conversion Funnel: How to Convert Visitors into Customers will take you through each stage of the conversion process from the time you arrive on your site to when you sell and follow up.

3. Give Each Page One Clear Primary CTA

Extra buttons don’t equate to more conversions.

When “Contact Us” and “Book a Call” and “Download Our Guide” and “View Portfolio” and “Learn More” and “Get Started” all vie for the visitor’s attention, you no longer have time to observe which one is more important.

Hone in on one main action.

Make it specific:

  • Schedule a Strategy Call to explore how we can help you.
  • Ask to get a Website Audit.
  • Get a Project Quote
  • Schedule a Consultation

A secondary action can be present if it is a way to achieve the primary action, but it is not dangerous to the primary action.

Your CTA should also indicate what to do next. “Submit” creates uncertainty. The action is now clearly stated as “Request a Website Audit.”

4. Remove Friction From Your Forms

You can get a person to feel convinced, interested, and prepared to contact you and still have them leave the form.

Take a look at the information you’re asking for. Does anyone really need to fill out a 500 word project description, address, phone number, company size, budget, preferred contact time, industry before they can ask a simple question?

Use the information your team requires starting with. Resolve any convoluted validation messages, clarify required fields and ensure the form is functional for mobile use.

Then talk about what happens once it has been submitted. When you write something like “We’ll get back to you within one business day”, you eliminate the uncertainties even if you don’t get back to the person right away.

5. Build Trust Before Asking for the Sale

You can communicate your value proposition, and they may still not want to take the plunge.

The next question is typically, “Can I believe this business?”

Don’t just state that you are experienced, provide evidence.

Trust signals that are useful are:

  • Client testimonials
  • Case studies
  • Reviews
  • Client logos
  • Certifications
  • Relevant results
  • The following are examples of work that was done in the past.
  • A clear process

Put proof close to the point where visitors are making a decision. The testimonials found on a separate page are less useful than the relevant proof next to the service or CTA that backs them.

6. Make Your Service Pages Easier to Decide From

A service page should respond to the queries that a prospective client may have before calling you.

At minimum, explain:

  • Problem you solve
  • The services provided by the Company.
  • Who it is for
  • How the process appears.The form of the process.
  • Explain why your method is unique.Explain why you are in a different approach.
  • What the next step is

Don’t let visitors have to follow a trail of links from page to page.

In this deep dive into the problem of weak messaging, unclear CTAs, unnecessary friction and service pages that are hard to scan, you’ll learn how to fix the problem that most service pages face.

7. Improve Mobile Conversion, Not Just Mobile Design

It’s possible to have a website that is responsive, but not easy to convert on a phone.

Open your important pages on a real mobile device and attempt to do the conversion on your own.

Do you need to scroll through a lot to see the CTA? Can buttons be easily tapped? Can the page be easily scanned? Is there a pop up that covers the content? Does the page take too long to load?

Don’t assume that an easy way to convert to a desktop application will be equally simple to use on mobile.

8. Find the Weakest Step Instead of Redesigning Everything

Don’t assume that if you don’t have a lot of conversions then you need to redesign the whole website.

Consider the trip.

For example:

  • A service page is visited by 10,000 people.
  • 2000 clicks through to the contact page.
  • 500 start the form.
  • 80% complete it.

The most important question is not ‘How do we drive more traffic?

Yes, it might be as simple as that: “Why do 420 people begin the form but not complete it?”

This might indicate extraneous fields, confusing instructions, technical issues, slow loading, or the form experience being different from the service-page promises.

By analyzing data, UX, messaging, funnels, forms, CTAs, trust signals, and traffic intent, WP Minds’ Conversion Rate Optimization Audit can help you uncover these leaks.

9. Test Changes Instead of Guessing

While not everything needs to be an A/B test, it’s important to track meaningful improvements.

If possible, make one change to the element at a time. If the landing page has a poor CTA then test a more specific CTA, not the headline, layout, form, images or CTA.

Track:

  • CTA clicks
  • Form starts
  • Form completions
  • Calls
  • Bookings
  • Purchases
  • Qualified leads

It’s not always better to have a higher click-through rate (CTR) if it’s not translating to good leads.

10. Keep Improving After the First Win

Turning into conversion optimization is not a project finished by itself.

The needs of visitors to your site can vary from one new service, audience, offer, traffic source, or pricing model.

Take the time to check important pages on a regular basis. Monitor all conversions, drop-offs, device performance and lead quality.

You might find that another headline, form that’s not as long, a stronger testimonial, or a better CTA is more useful than another iteration of visual redesign.

You May Not Need More Traffic Yet

When a site has already proven itself to be a good converter, more traffic is a good thing. But if the visitors are coming in and out without taking any action, then you’re just getting more visitors that don’t convert.

Begin with existing traffic.

Clarify the message. Match Pages to Intent. Strengthen trust. Remove unnecessary friction. Be clear about what needs to happen next. Next, note the changes that are measured.

If you’re in need of assistance with determining where visitors are losing momentum, WP Minds Website Consulting Services can give you a more comprehensive website strategy analysis and review of your website user experience, messaging, and conversion path.

It is not necessarily a greater number of visitors who will bring more traffic to your website.

Sometimes it’s necessary to make the people already there easier to say, “yes”.

Komal Haider
Komal Haider Website Growth Expert

Building a website that drives traffic and generates leads is challenging. Komal is a website growth expert at WP Minds, a website consulting service that helps coaches, trainers, authors, and creatives to create winning website strategy, develop high converting websites, attract visitors and convert leads into customers to grow their businesses.