A visitor clicks on your website. They enjoy your service, but they still have one question:

“Will this really work for me?”

You can let them know how long you have been in business. Shows them that others have vested their trust in you before.

Just putting a slider of 5-star quotes on your home page isn’t enough though. Well written testimonials provide visitors with some evidence that is relevant to their circumstances, addresses an objection or demonstrates the effect of working with you.

Testimonials can be a part of the conversion journey, not just a design element if they are used well.

Start With the Question Your Visitor Is Asking

Consider the visitor’s next step when selecting a testimonial.

Any visitor to your home page could be wondering, “Are these folks believable?”

When someone visits a service page, they might be wondering, “Have they done this thing before?”

When an individual views a booking page, he or she is probably asking what it is going to really be like to work with them.

The recommendation should be of assistance in answering that question.

That is why it’s often not best to copy the same three quotes onto each page. The content on your website should complement the various steps of the visitors’ journey. Learn more about how trust signals play in the bigger picture of the website conversion journey with WP Minds’ Website Conversion Guide.

1. Choose Testimonials That Say Something Specific

They are highly recommended, I can tell you that!

It’s a good thing, but it doesn’t provide much information for the potential customer.

A better form of testimonial would be to explain:

  • What was the issue the customer was facing/having? 
  • Why they chose you
  • How it felt to experience it.
  • What changed afterward

Compare:

Weak: “Excellent service and good staff. Highly recommend!”

Stronger: “The website was getting lots of traffic with few enquiries – they made our messaging more straightforward and restructured the relevant pages around our services and now our website is getting more qualified enquiries.

The second provides a reader with some context and an outcome to which they can relate.

Not all of the testimonials need to include impressive numbers. An unambiguous result may be as helpful.

2. Match the Testimonial to the Page and Decision Point

The place where the testimonial is placed is just as important as the content of the testimonial.

A testimonial on the home page can build credibility. A quote from a service page is a great way to demonstrate a service’s effectiveness. When a person visits the page, a testimonial can help take away the last little hesitation that will be standing in their way from contacting you.

If you provide website redesign services, for instance, a testimonial from a client who had trouble with an outdated website and now gets more enquiries after the redesign is more pertinent than a general praise.

In such cases, it’s worth using testimonials where visitors are taking a decision.

  • Under your fundamental proposition
  • This service provides a description of the services
  • Unusual location.Close to a price or package
  • The CTA is located next to a consultation
  • On booking or product pages
  • Within pertinent landing pages

Even with a number of customer stories, it can be helpful to have a dedicated testimonial page if you can categorize them by service, industry, or result. The Website Conversion Funnel for WP Minds covers the evaluation stage, and there are examples for your testimonial page of quote testimonials, video testimonials, case studies, customer reviews, and more.

3. Use Testimonials to Address Objections

Good testimonials can overcome objections, but not sound like sales copy.

If visitors are concerned that your service is costly, demonstrate to them a customer who has received value out of your service.

If they are concerned about the process being difficult, include a testimonial mentioning how simple the process was.

If they’re not sure you’re familiar with their industry, highlight another person who is.

Consider what are your typical sales questions and objections. If you already have some feedback, scan your past feedback for responses that address these.

This makes social proof much more strategic.

4. Give the Customer Enough Context

Without context, a quote may sound like a random historical fact.

If applicable, add the customer’s name, picture, company, job title or location. Not all of the information needs to be presented all the time; select information that is relevant to the audience to whom you are presenting the testimonial.

If you are dealing with a B2B website, then “Sarah, Marketing Director” will serve you more than just “Sarah”.

The idea is to make the testimonial seem relevant and believable.

5. Don’t Edit the Life Out of a Testimonial

It’s easy to reword all of the customer quotes into a pretty marketing piece.

Resist it.

Correct obvious spelling or grammar errors if needed; maintain the tone of the customer. A sentence that isn’t quite right can seem more authentic than one that is from the marketing department.

When providing a shorter testimonial, ensure that there is no change in the meaning. Do not alter customer quotes so that they say something they never said.

6. Turn Strong Testimonials Into Mini Case Studies

Sometimes, the feedback from customers is too valuable to present with just one or two lines.

If they tell you what their problem was, what you did to solve it and what was the outcome, you might have a beginning of a case study.

For example:

Before: Client was used to referrals and outdated websites.

During: Cleaned up the messaging, restructured the service pages and reworked the path to conversion.

Following: Client’s sales process became more clear and they started to receive more relevant enquiries.

That story helps to put the compliment into perspective.

The full story will fit on a single page, and can be cut down for the homepage or a service page.

7. Choose the Right Format and Make It Easy to Scan

Written evidence can be scanned easily. Video can help give this tone and personality; and case studies can help visitors gain more information before deciding.

Yet another layer of social proof can be reviews and user-generated content.

If you don’t need all formats. Select what works with the customers’ decision-making process.

Regardless of the format, make key information easily accessible. Instead, focus on a helpful sentence, organize longer stories into parts, compile service or outcome-based testimonials, or utilize video thumbnails rather than having visitors navigate through a block of text.

Also, for Landing Pages, WP Minds’ Landing Page Design Best Practices considers how social proof can help build trust without diverting traffic away from the primary call to action.

8. Keep Your Testimonials Current

But a page dedicated to testimonials with feedback that’s 5 or 10 years old can stir an uncomfortable sentiment:

“Is there still a demand for this business?”

Periodically check your testimonials.

Include recent customer experience. When an outdated reference no longer represents your business, remove the reference. Ensure names, companies, services and results are correct.

It’s OK if you don’t need dozens of testimonials. A more targeted and focused set of comments on specific, recent work may be helpful than a wall of praise.

9. Connect Testimonials to the Next Step

A testimonial should support the decision, not become the end of the journey.

After a visitor reads a relevant success story, make the next step obvious.

For example:

“See how we can improve your website” → service page

“Want results like these?” → consultation

“See the full project” → case study

The proof should lead somewhere.

How to Get Better Testimonials From Customers

The issue could be how you ask for testimonials if your current ones are not specific.

Rather than asking the customer, “Would you leave us a testimonial?” provide some cues:

  • What issue(s) were you looking to resolve?
  • What made you select us?
  • How was it?
  • What resulted from working with us?
  • What would you say about our services to an individual who is thinking about joining?

These questions help customers be more helpful and are more likely to retain their tone.

The Best Testimonials Help Visitors See Themselves

The hallmark of a good customer testimonial goes beyond claiming that your business is great.

It serves as a reference for the next visitor.

They encounter a person who has a similar problem, situation, industry or goal. They witness and see how it was experienced. They can identify the differences. And they can begin to envision this for themselves.

This is why testimonials are best viewed and utilized within your website and conversion plan rather than a list of compliments on one page.

For any testimonials, make sure they’re relevant to a decision, do not lose the customer’s voice, provide context, and tie it to a next action for the reader.

If you’re not sure if your website is implementing trust signals, WP Minds’ Website Consulting Services can help you find the areas where you’re missing the mark with messaging, user experience, and conversion paths.

Your website can describe to your visitors what you do.

Your customers have the opportunity to give them a compelling reason to trust you.

Rana
Rana Website Development Consultant

Building a website that drives traffic and generates leads is challenging. Rana is a website development consultant and a Co-Founder of WP Minds, a website consulting service that helps coaches, trainers, authors, and creatives to create winning website strategy, develop high converting websites, attract visitors and convert leads into customers to grow their businesses.