Offering a smooth payment experience is key to building client confidence and getting paid on time.
Whether you’re selling one-on-one sessions, group programs, or monthly memberships, your payment gateway plays a crucial role in the client journey.
Two of the most popular options for online payments are Stripe and PayPal — but which one is right for your coaching website?Â
This article explores the pros and cons of Stripe and PayPal for coaching websites—and helps you choose the best payment solution for 2025.
Quick Comparison: Stripe vs PayPal (at a Glance)
If you’re short on time, here’s a quick side-by-side comparison of Stripe and PayPal to help you understand the key differences:
This quick snapshot gives you a starting point, but the best choice depends on how your coaching business operates. Let’s explore each option in more detail.
Stripe for Coaching Websites
Stripe is a powerful payment gateway that’s popular among tech-savvy coaches and online business owners.Â
It offers a seamless checkout experience that keeps clients on your website, helping build trust and reduce friction during payment.
Key Features for Coaches:
- Customizable checkout pages
- Built-in support for subscriptions and recurring billing
- Easy integration with tools like WP Simple Pay, MemberPress, or Kajabi
- Accepts major credit/debit cards and digital wallets like Apple Pay and Google Pay
Pros of Using Stripe:
- Seamless and branded client experience
- Excellent for subscription-based programs or memberships
- Lower dispute rate compared to PayPal
- Advanced reporting and analytics
Cons of Using Stripe:
- Requires some technical setup or plugins
- Not as instantly recognizable to all clients
- Can be overkill if you only offer one-off sessions
Stripe is best suited for coaches who run group programs, offer monthly packages, or want to scale their business with subscriptions.
If your site is built on WordPress or another platform that integrates well with Stripe, it can be a game-changer for your client experience.
PayPal for Coaching Websites
PayPal is one of the most widely recognized payment gateways worldwide, making it a trusted option for coaches looking to offer a straightforward, easy-to-use payment solution.Â
Its simplicity and recognition make it an appealing choice for many coaches, especially if you are offering one-off sessions or low-cost services.
Key Features for Coaches:
- Simple and fast setup process
- Allows for one-time payments and subscriptions
- Global reach with support for multiple currencies
- Integration with platforms like WordPress and coaching tools like Calendly
Pros of Using PayPal:
- Easy setup process with no technical expertise required
- High trust factor with clients, especially those who prefer using PayPal’s account for payment
- Ideal for one-time payments and low-cost services
- Supports international payments and multiple currencies
Cons of Using PayPal:
- Limited branding and customization options for checkout
- Clients are redirected to PayPal’s site during checkout, which may feel less professional
- Higher chargeback risk compared to Stripe, as PayPal tends to favor customers in disputes
PayPal is ideal if you’re running a coaching business with one-off sessions or relatively simple pricing.
If you prefer an easy-to-implement solution that clients are familiar with, PayPal is a strong choice — especially if you’re just getting started.
What Should a Coach Consider Before Choosing?
Choosing the right payment gateway for your coaching business depends on a variety of factors.
Here are some key considerations to help you make the best decision:
1. Your Website Platform
Make sure the payment gateway integrates smoothly with your website.
Platforms like WordPress, Kajabi, and Teachable work well with both Stripe and PayPal, but it’s important to check compatibility with your specific website setup.
2. Your Technical Comfort Level
Stripe typically requires more technical setup, especially if you want to fully customize your checkout process.
If you’re not tech-savvy, PayPal’s straightforward setup might be a better option.
However, there are plugins and integrations that can simplify Stripe’s use on your site.
3. Your Business Model
- One-off Sessions: If you offer individual coaching sessions, PayPal might be the best choice
- Recurring Payments & Memberships: If you run subscription-based programs, Stripe’s robust support for recurring billing may be more suitable.
- Packages: For coaches who sell coaching packages, both options can work, but Stripe provides a more seamless experience for recurring payments.
4. Your Clients’ Preferences
Consider your target market. If your clients are more likely to be familiar with PayPal, it could be a trusted option to build their confidence.
However, if you’re targeting a more tech-savvy audience, Stripe’s sleek, seamless payment experience could be a stronger fit.
5. Do You Need Both?
Many coaches use both Stripe and PayPal to offer clients a choice. This can increase conversions by allowing clients to pay through their preferred method.
However, it’s important to balance simplicity and not overwhelm clients with too many options.
Can You Use Both Stripe and PayPal?
Yes, you can absolutely use both Stripe and PayPal on your coaching website, and it might even be a good strategy to cater to a wider range of clients.
Offering both options allows your clients to choose the payment method they are most comfortable with, which can help increase conversions and satisfaction.
How to Implement Both:
- Payment Options Page: You can display both Stripe and PayPal buttons on your checkout page.
- Integrate Both with Your Platform: Many website builders, like WordPress or Kajabi, allow easy integration of both Stripe and PayPal
Things to Keep in Mind:
- Tracking and Reporting: Using both can sometimes complicate your payment reporting, as you’ll need to check each platform separately for your earnings.
- Fees: Be mindful of the potential fees that might vary between the two platforms. Make sure to account for these costs in your pricing structure.
- Customer Experience: Offering too many payment options can sometimes confuse clients.
Using both payment gateways is a viable option if you want to maximize convenience for your clients. Just be sure it fits your workflow and doesn’t overcomplicate the payment experience.
Conclusion
Choosing between Stripe and PayPal depends on your coaching business model, your technical comfort level, and your clients’ preferences.
Both gateways offer strong features, but each has its advantages.
- Stripe is ideal for coaches looking for a customizable, seamless checkout experience and those offering subscription-based programs or memberships.
- PayPal is a great option if you need an easy, quick setup and prefer a widely recognized platform with international reach.
Need Help Setting Up Your Payment Gateway?
Whether you need assistance with integrating Stripe or PayPal, or guidance on choosing the right solution for your coaching business, get in touch with us today and let’s get your payments running smoothly!
From setting up a payment gateway to maintaining your website’s performance, security, and updates, we handle the technical side so you can focus on what you do best—coaching your clients to success.
Check out our maintenance plans and get started with effortless payment processing today!
Request a Quote for Your Professional Website
"*" indicates required fields
Our Portfolio
IGT Law
HogBox
Power Law Firm
Lester Dominic
Beckiowens
Holistic Natural Health Experts
Alix Dunn
Net Concepts
Grow Strong Teams
Kite Child
Vest right
Cody Bjugan
Maine beds
Dr2Dr Coaching
Dr. Leslie Korn
Integral Somatic Psychology
Organic Intelligence | Trauma Safe
NeuroAffective Touch
DOWNLOAD YOUR FREE PDF AND DISCOVER THE PROVEN STEPS TO CREATE A HIGH-PERFORMING WEBSITE FOR YOUR BUSINESS.
About
Komal
Is Your Website Working Hard As You Do?
Our Free Audit Checks Everything From Performance

To SEO, Giving You A Road Map To Success
Free & No Obligation
